I live in a small town which is surrouned by beautiful lakes?这里引导词怎么不用where？

Question

我住在一个被美丽的湖包围的小城镇。 住在一个地方 不能用where引导的么，为什么。那么where用在哪?求解？

Answer 1

这里的which修饰的是small town
当句子中缺少状语时可用where
或者，说的更通俗些，题目表达的是：我住在一个小城镇上，小城镇被湖泊包围着。如果把which改成where，那么它的意思就变了，变成了：我住在一个小城镇上，在小城镇上被湖泊包围着。句子就不通了，不知道你懂没懂，欢迎继续提问

Answer 2

此处为定语从句，a small town是先行词，which是引导词，拆分之后是
I live in a small town.
The small town is surrounded by beautiful lakes.

where是引导状语从句的，表示地点时相当于in which，在句中作状语。
如I live in a small town where there are many beautiful lakes.拆分之后是
I live in a small town.

In the small town there are many beautiful lakes.

In the small town在句中做地点状语本回答被提问者和网友采纳

Answer 3

这里which代替的是a small town，做定语从句的主语，因此用which。
如果代替in a small town, 做状语，就用 where
关键看关系代词在【定语从句】中的成分：A small town is surrouned by beautiful lakes